Meghan Markle Aide Breaks Silence on Bullying Allegations
Meghan Markle’s former top aide has confirmed for the first time that she was interviewed as part of a palace review into allegations the royal bullied her staff.
The Duchess of Sussex was accused of forcing two PAs out of Kensington Palace in a 2018 internal email that was leaked to U.K. broadsheet The Times days before her Oprah Winfrey interview in 2021. Meghan has always denied the allegations.
At the time the complaint was first made, Samantha Cohen was her private secretary, the most senior adviser who reports to a royal.
Cohen, who is Australian, gave an interview to Australian newspaper the Herald Sun in which she was asked about the bullying allegations.
The newspaper reported she would only confirm she was one of 10 staffers who were interviewed as part of a Buckingham Palace probe into the bullying allegations.
However, she added: “I was only supposed to stay for six months but stayed for 18—we couldn’t find a replacement for me and when we did we took them on tour to Africa with Harry and Meghan to show them the ropes but they left (quit) as well while in Africa.”
The Duke and Duchess of Sussex toured Southern Africa in September and October 2019, shortly before they left Britain for Canada that November.
Jason Knauf, then-Kensington Palace communications secretary, sent an email in October 2018 to Simon Case, Prince William’s private secretary at the time, outlining concerns about Meghan’s treatment of staff.
Knauf told Case: “I am very concerned that the duchess was able to bully two PAs out of the household in the past year. The treatment of X [name removed] was totally unacceptable.”
“The Duchess seems intent on always having someone in her sights,” Knauf continued. “She is bullying Y [name removed] and seeking to undermine her confidence. We have had report after report from people who have witnessed unacceptable behavior towards Y [name removed].”
The bullying allegations have a long history and first entered the public domain in watered down form two months later in December 2018 with a story in The Sunday Times about Cohen’s departure from Kensington Palace.
The headline read: “Meghan loses second close aide, Samantha Cohen, as rumours swirl of ‘Duchess Difficult,'” while the article suggested she had been known to send requests as early as 5 a.m.
A source told the newspaper Cohen’s replacement would need “reserves of energy and patience to help her define her future role.”
However, the full scale of the allegations remained secret until the days before Meghan and Prince Harry’s March 2021 Oprah Winfrey interview when Knauf’s email was leaked to The Times and published.
The Sussexes came back fighting with a statement that read: “Let’s just call this what it is—a calculated smear campaign based on misleading and harmful misinformation. We are disappointed to see this defamatory portrayal of the Duchess of Sussex given credibility by a media outlet.”
However, over time Meghan’s stance appeared to soften and her lawyer, Jenny Afia, later told the BBC: “What bullying actually means is improperly using power, repeatedly and deliberately to hurt someone physically or emotionally.
“The Duchess of Sussex has absolutely denied doing that. That said, she wouldn’t want to negate anyone’s personal experiences.”
Harry also denied that Meghan was a bully in his book Spare, but did acknowledge the existence of a toxic culture at Kensington Palace in which he saw staff weep.
“Nerves were shattering, people were sniping,” he wrote. “In such a climate there was no such thing as constructive criticism. All feedback was seen as an affront, an insult.
“More than once a staff member slumped across their desk and wept. For all this, every bit of it, Willy blamed one person. Meg.”
“Meg managed to remain calm,” he continued. “Despite what certain people were saying about her, I never heard her speak a bad word about anybody, or to anybody.
“On the contrary, I watched her redouble her efforts to reach out, to spread kindness.”
Harry also denied Meghan forced out one of her PAs, though he did acknowledge the Sussexes played a role in her departure.
“She [Meghan] was also said to have driven our assistant to quit,” he wrote. “In fact that assistant was asked to resign by Palace HR after we showed them evidence she’d traded on her position with Meg to get freebies.”
Buckingham Palace launched an internal review of the bullying allegations in 2021 and initially suggested a report would be made public. Ultimately, however, the findings were never disclosed.
The main legacy of the saga may in the long term be the role it played in showing publicly that the palace had their own narrative that contradicted Harry and Meghan’s.
Harry said during their Oprah Winfrey interview that the royals were initially welcoming of Meghan but it all changed with a raft of hostile leaks to the media after a tour of Australia and the South Pacific in Fall 2021.
The only explanation he appeared to offer was that it was “the first time that the family got to see how incredible she is at the job.”
The bullying allegations served as another alternative explanation for how royal relations soured that countered Harry’s narrative that the royals were simply jealous of Meghan.
Jack Royston is Newsweek’s chief royal correspondent based in London. You can find him on X, formerly Twitter, at @jack_royston and read his stories on Newsweek’s The Royals Facebook page.
Do you have a question about King Charles III, William and Kate Middleton, Meghan Markle and Harry, or their family that you would like our experienced royal correspondents to answer? Email [email protected]. We’d love to hear from you.
Meghan Markle Aide Breaks Silence on Bullying Allegations
Meghan Markle’s Brother Says He’s Hurt Her
Princess Kate’s Reaction to Being Tickled Caught on Camera
Start your unlimited Newsweek trial
Fullscreen button
Meghan Markle is seen with her former private secretary Samantha Cohen [center] and Queen Elizabeth II at the opening of the new Mersey Gateway Bridge, in Widnes, England, on June 14, 2018. Cohen confirmed she was interviewed for a palace review following bullying allegations against Meghan.
Meghan Markle is seen with her former private secretary Samantha Cohen [center] and Queen Elizabeth II at the opening of the new Mersey Gateway Bridge, in Widnes, England, on June 14, 2018. Cohen confirmed she was interviewed for a palace review following bullying allegations against Meghan. © Max Mumby/Indigo/Getty Images
Fullscreen button
Jason Knauf, then Kensington Palace communications secretary, is seen during a visit to Leicester City Football Club’s King Power Stadiumon November 28, 2018. He lodged bullying allegations against Meghan Markle a month earlier. Max Mumby/Indigo/Getty Images
Support great journalism
and enjoy unlimited ad free access
NewsweekVisit Newsweek
IRS Updates Millions of Taxpayers After Tax Day
Donald Trump Raises Over $1 Million on First Day of Trial: Lara Trump
‘Socially Anxious’ Labradoodle Taken to Dog Park, Goes Exactly as Expected
Sponsored Content
Innovate w/ Manufacturing TechInnovate w/ Manufacturing Tech more
Ho Chi Minh: Jewelry On Sale For Half Price! (See Price List)Ho Chi Minh: Jewelry On Sale For Half Price! (See Price List) more
No Residency RequirementNo Residency Requirement more
More for You
No Residency RequirementNo Residency Requirement more
OPINION – How dare Montecito millionaire Prince Harry demand our tax money to cover his legal costsOPINION – How dare Montecito millionaire Prince Harry demand our tax money to cover his legal costs Evening Standard
Prince William finds ally in Kate Middleton’s mother Carole amid royal health woes: expertPrince William finds ally in Kate Middleton’s mother Carole amid royal health woes: expert FOX News
Taylor Swift reacts to Ryan Gosling and Emily Blunt’s ‘All Too Well’ cover on ‘SNL’Taylor Swift reacts to Ryan Gosling and Emily Blunt’s ‘All Too Well’ cover on ‘SNL’ FOX News
O.J. Simpson’s Lawyer Reverses Opinion on Payments to Goldman FamilyO.J. Simpson’s Lawyer Reverses Opinion on Payments to Goldman Family Hollywood Reporter
Rudy Gobert Reflects on Family Members’ Racism Toward Him as a Child: ‘We Don’t Want That Baby in Our House’Rudy Gobert Reflects on Family Members’ Racism Toward Him as a Child: ‘We Don’t Want That Baby in Our House’ Complex
Buy Pronamel Mouthwash TodayBuy Pronamel Mouthwash Today more
Access all TV channels anywhere, anytimeAccess all TV channels anywhere, anytime more
Kate Middleton undergoing treatment for cancer: Everything to know about her healthKate Middleton undergoing treatment for cancer: Everything to know about her health TODAY
Princess Diana Reportedly Told Queen Elizabeth That Prince Charles Was a “Nightmare”Princess Diana Reportedly Told Queen Elizabeth That Prince Charles Was a “Nightmare” InStyle
Critics spare no mercy for billionaire heiress Nicola Peltz’s ‘vanity project’ Lola: ‘Awful beyond my wildest expectations’
Critics spare no mercy for billionaire heiress Nicola Peltz’s ‘vanity project’ Lola: ‘Awful beyond my wildest expectations’ – Actor has written and starred in her self-directed film ‘Lola’
Critics spare no mercy for billionaire heiress Nicola Peltz’s ‘vanity project’ Lola: ‘Awful beyond my wildest expectations’ The Independent
All of Prince William’s Rumored Ex-GirlfriendsAll of Prince William’s Rumored Ex-Girlfriends ELLE US
Make Prince Harry’s visa application public, campaigners demand amid ‘drug-use’ lawsuit
Story by Emma Guinness
Campaigners are demanding Prince Harry’s US visa application be made public after Joe Biden’s advisor asserted that the current president would under no circumstances deport the prince.
The comments were made by ambassador Jane Hartley in response to former president, Donald Trump, who said that if reelected he would treat Harry like any other citizen should it emerge that he has broken the law.
Prince Harry’s visa application is currently being reviewed in private after the Duke of Sussex admitted to doing drugs in his 2023 memoir, Spare.
This was picked up on by various readers, who noted that in order to apply for a US visa, a person must answer questions about their prior drug use.
The think tank group The Heritage Foundation subsequently launched a lawsuit to ascertain whether or not Harry lied on his application.
The Department of Homeland Security (DHS) refused to make the documents public when they were first requested last June, stating that there was no “public interest in disclosure sufficient to override the subject’s privacy interests”.
The Heritage Foundation, however, now believes that disclosure is now very much in the public interest.
“Ambassador Hartley’s statements dramatically enhance the already compelling public interest in disclosure,” they said, describing the claim as “extraordinary”.
The think tank group claims that the DHS said “none of the information that we have can be released without acknowledging what Prince Harry’s immigration status is or tipping our hand as to what it is.”
Nile Gardiner, Director of the Heritage Foundation’s Margaret Thatcher Center for Freedom, said: “The US Ambassador to London’s arrogant remarks on Prince Harry are an extraordinary intervention by a senior US diplomat on an ongoing federal court case.
“The US Ambassador’s remarks clearly spoke directly not only to the Duke of Sussex’s current immigration status, but to Prince Harry’s future immigration status as well.
“The Biden Administration has gone to great lengths to protect Prince Harry, and has even ruled out the possible deportation of the Duke of Sussex if he lied on his U.S. immigration application and violated US immigration law.
“The Biden Administration has acted without transparency and accountability to the American people regarding the Heritage Foundation’s Freedom of Information request relating to Prince Harry’s US immigration application. They should release Harry’s immigration records to the American people.”
The duke, 39, recounted using various substances during his tumultuous youth in the book – citing one example of drug use as recently as 2016.
He wrote: “Psychedelics did me some good as well. I’d experimented with them over the years, for fun, but now I’d begun to use them therapeutically, medicinally. They didn’t simply allow me to escape reality for a while.
“They let me redefine reality. Under the influence of these substances, I was able to let go of rigid preconcepts, to see that there was another world beyond my heavily filtered senses, a world that was equally real and doubly beautiful – a world with no red mist.”
The Independent has approached reprsentatives for Prince Harry for comment.
The Independent is the world’s most free-thinking news brand, providing global news, commentary and analysis for the independently-minded. We have grown a huge, global readership of independently minded individuals, who value our trusted voice and commitment to positive change. Our mission, making change happen, has never been as important as it is today.
